Showing posts with label mediumship research. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mediumship research. Show all posts

Wednesday, 10 June 2026

Founding the Noah’s Ark Society to Save Physical Mediumship

Back in 1990 (nearly 30 years ago now), I founded the Noah’s Ark Society (NAS) to help save physical mediumship – which, at that time, appeared set to become extinct. Many of the few remaining physical mediums who were demonstrating in public at that time were elderly, deteriorating in health, and undertaking less and less work as their mediumships ‘wound down’.

For instance, within the next four years, two of the best known physical mediums – Gordon Higginson and Leslie Flint both passed to Spirit. Several other well-known physical mediums, such as Maud Gunning and Geoffrey Jacobs, had already passed to Spirit a little earlier as well. Some genuine physical mediums such as Rita Goold (who was working in a different energy-based way) had been forced to discontinue their mediumship due to alarming threats (including death threats) from anonymous ‘Arch Sceptics’ who – without any proof – accused them of fraud. Some excellent physical mediums like John Squires of Romford simply gave up because of health issues.

Ilkeston Physical mediumship circle

With the public’s increasing lack of access to séances and demonstrations of physical mediumship, and the lack of any exciting reports regarding encouraging contemporary results in this unique field of mediumship, it was perhaps inevitable that public interest in the subject would fade away. Instead of witnessing available demonstrations of physical mediumship (the publicity of which, naturally, would have generated considerable interest from scientists and the public), and since practical experience was sadly lacking, anyone seeking more knowledge and information was forced to go to the history books for answers! I remember more than one person at that time remarking to me: “Physical Mediumship – isn’t that something that happened way back in time – but is no longer being practiced?”

In 1989, my wife Sandra and I moved into a rented Church of England Rectory at Postwick – just a few miles East of Norwich. For many years, we had run our own home circles for the development of physical phenomena in the Romford area and had, in fact, actually met in a physical circle at Romford where the medium John Squires went on to develop the Independent Voice phenomenon (of an excellent quality) to almost rival that of Leslie Flint. My own interest as a researcher of physical mediumship goes back to 1972.

Once at Postwick, it was not long before I began to miss the home circles we had run and, although we did ask around the area, we never discovered any physical home circles who were looking for sitters at that time. Consequentially, a little later, we did once again start our own home circle at Postwick – but that is another story.

In the meantime, in March 1989, an advert for sitters in a physical circle at Ilkeston, Derbyshire appeared in the ‘Psychic News’. I replied and agreed to meet the trance medium of that circle, Stuart Hellen and his wife Valarie, for a chat. Although the circle was 130 miles away from Postwick, they had been asked by their Spirit Team to start a physical circle, running just once per month on the Saturday closest to the new moon. The traveling was therefore not too frequent, and when asked, I was happy to join the circle.

Regular communicators in the Ilkeston Group

physical mediumship
Woodbury type on paper mount, late 1860s-1870s

​See page for author, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

In April 1989, I was present at their first proper physical phenomena sitting. Several raps occurred, together with psychic breezes, and ‘whistling’ was clearly heard over the singing of the group. Later in the year, after a few more sittings, I was able to arrange for the circle members to visit Leslie Flint, whom I had known for several years. Through his Independent Voice mediumship, the group received confirmation of the work they were doing to develop physical mediumship, and much evidence concerning the circle. The well-known Victorian Novelist and Spiritualist Florence Marryat (1833-1899) also became a regular communicator in the Ilkeston Group. Her book ‘There Is No Death’ is one I can highly recommend!

Stuart Hellen’s mediumistic development continued apace and early in 1990, at the request of the Spirit Team, Stuart’s chair was moved into a cabinet and during this first ‘cabinet’ sitting, the circle was taken unawares when the initial attempt at Independent Voice took place. This phenomena continued to develop during the further sittings in 1990.

In late 1989, another advert had appeared in the ‘Psychic News’ for sitters to attend another physical circle – this time in Hove, near Brighton. Again (and I shall never know quite why!) I replied, despite the fact that this circle was actually 140 miles away from our home – in a totally different direction. This group was run by John Austin, a veteran Spiritualist and his wife Gerry. They too knew Leslie Flint well. Although it was a weekly circle, I joined this group, too.

After sitting with the circle for a number of months, John and Gerry decided that they needed a new carpet for the lounge in which their sittings took place. The manager of a local carpet warehouse called to measure up the room, and instinctively made the comment that he knew what that room was used for. ‘Séances!’ There was no way he could have known this by normal means, so John and Gerry chatted to him about their interest. The result was that the young man Colin Fry was asked to join the circle. He agreed, and history was born! It was not long before Colin’s physical mediumship took off, and he started to go into deep trance. In terms of physical phenomena, his development was quite rapid. Within months, advanced examples of physical phenomena were taking place and by mid 1990, it was apparent that he was going to be an excellent physical medium. I personally witnessed one of the first instances of his phenomena, when a coin was suddenly apported into the centre of the circle from the medium’s solar plexus. Later, when levitation of the medium became commonplace, he was once levitated, complete with chair, through a wall into the next room!

How the Noah’s Ark Society was born

Meanwhile, back at the Ilkeston Circle in May 1990, it was on the anniversary of the inaugural meeting of the ‘Link of Home Circles’ (held in 1931 and attended by its founder – Mr Noah Zerdin) that a spirit personality communicated with us in the Independent Direct Voice. This was no less than Noah Zerdin himself, who had been a mentor to Leslie Flint in his early days, and many other mediums besides. He specifically asked us to: “Start a Society which would educate the public about physical mediumship – ensuring its safe development, demonstration and practice – as well as generally promoting physical mediumship and its phenomena to the public”.

This, for us, was a very exciting development, and we quickly realised the significance of such a message, and the importance of actually implementing Noah Zerdin’s request. After the sitting, we sat round discussing the possibility of starting such a society. Since I had more experience in this specialist type of mediumship and its phenomena than the others, I agreed to take over the responsibilities and practicalities of putting the society together, and badgered the other circle members to join me on the initial committee to help with the basic work (which involved an awful lot of diplomatic persuasion!)

At that time, I was in a reasonable position financially and was able to fund the society in its early days out of my own pocket. I came up with the name myself – The Noah’s Ark Society (I guess with a little help from Spirit), and commissioned an art studio in Norwich to produce a suitable logo. The name was suitable for three reasons:

1)  The ‘Noah’ referred to Noah Zerdin, who had been the spirit communicator who asked us to start the Society.

2)  Biblically speaking, ‘Noah’s Ark’ was a vessel that saved many species of animals from their ultimate extinction. The Noah’s Ark Society aimed to save a particular form of mediumship – physical mediumship – from extinction too.

3)  The ‘Ark of the Covenant’ – biblically speaking – was a repository for psychic power and spiritual knowledge. That seemed particularly appropriate here too!

Over the next few weeks, I placed adverts regularly throughout the psychic press to notify the public of the new organization. We sent out information sheets to interested people, detailing the aims and objects of the new Society, and inviting them to join the NAS. There was to be a monthly newsletter starting in August 1990 with Issue 1 and although much preparatory work had been done before that date (including the rapid recruitment of members), it was generally accepted that the Society would be officially formed in that month.

The very first member – number 001 – was Stewart Alexander. He agreed to join the committee and to be the ‘Archive Officer’. However, it was to be quite some time before he actually admitted to me that he was a physical medium himself! I started the Newsletter as planned, and edited it. In those early days it was produced by me on a photocopier (initially at my workplace, starting at 5.50am!)

The first committee consisted of just the members of the Ilkeston Circle, together with Stewart Alexander. I did not want to take on the mantle of ‘President’ myself, preferring instead to remain as ‘General Secretary’, which allowed me to quietly get on with the building, expansion and running of the Society. It was agreed by all that the first ‘President’ would be the medium – Stuart Hellen. The first ‘Treasurer’ was Denise Lacey, another Ilkeston sitter. Apart from Stewart as ‘Archive Officer’, the rest of the committee was made up by: Stuart’s wife Valarie Hellen; Michelle Hackett; Mark Stanley and Jaquie Turner.

The psychic press reported and trumpeted the details of the new Society. Because of that, our adverts, and ‘word of mouth’ generally, the NAS membership grew rapidly over the first few months. Physical circles from all over the world joined as well, together with dozens of individual interested people and researchers. We quickly surpassed the significant benchmark of 100 members, and approached 200. All of a sudden, it became clear that as well as the committed physical circles and researchers already involved in our specialist subject, there was also – amongst those who had never come across physical mediumship themselves before the advent of the NAS – a new, and massive interest in physical mediumship and its phenomena from the general public, many of whom were totally lacking ANY knowledge of the reality of physical phenomena. The NAS, therefore, provided a rallying point for interested people. We set out a programme of education so that everyone could learn the basic facts and so that members who had not previously done so, could witness demonstrations of physical mediumship themselves on a regular basis.

I wrote a NAS teaching guide on the ‘Development of Physical Mediumship and its Phenomena’, based on the traditional use of ‘ectoplasm’ (at that early stage, nobody knew that excellent phenomena could be produced using only ‘energy’. The ‘Scole Experiment’ and its work came later.) This, like the Newsletter, was produced in large numbers by me on my work’s copier machine, with a copy of this teaching booklet being sent out free to all members – together with Newsletter number 2 in September, 1990.

Over the next few months, the NAS continued to grow at a rapid rate, and the contacts that we made through the Society proved to be most useful. At a general meeting in January 1991, veteran medium and researcher Alan Crossley was elected as the new ‘President’, and I became ‘Chairman’ of the Noah’s Ark Society – a position I held until Sandra and I withdrew from the NAS in September 1994 (at the specific request of our Scole Spirit Team), to concentrate on our work with the Scole Experimental Group, which was producing some really amazing and exclusive Physical Phenomena – working in a brand new ‘energy-based’

physical mediumship

The first NAS physical mediumship demonstration

At a residential Seminar in Leicester in May (with almost 100 people present), the very first NAS demonstration of Physical Mediumship took place, using medium Colin Fry (at that time identified simply as ‘Lincoln’). It was a huge success and – Stewart Alexander (who was present) recognised the importance and full impact of such a public demonstration. He was immediately motivated to offer to undertake similar public demonstrations for the NAS in the future so – for many years, members were able to witness demonstrations of physical mediumship by these two superb mediums.

Stewart Alexander later took over as ‘President’ of the Noah’s Ark Society. The last ‘President’, the late George Cranley, engineered the closing of the NAS in 2004. The ‘Vice-President’ at that time was the late Colin Fry – a superb Physical Medium.

It is quite clear today that there is now a massive interest in Physical Mediumship and its phenomena all over the world. Newer (and often younger) physical mediums are developing and coming on to the scene in so many different countries. I have no doubt personally that the work of the Noah’s Ark Society and the later work of the Scole Experimental Group have contributed tremendously to that interest, and motivated a large number of those emerging physical mediums to develop their own mediumship and phenomena.

In conclusion, therefore, I think I can justly claim that the ‘Noah’s Ark Society’, which set out to ‘save’ Physical Mediumship and its phenomena achieved, in part, exactly what it set out to do. The subject (and practice) of Physical Mediumship today is thriving and continuing to expand constantly. Therefore it is far more commonplace (and available to the public) than it used to be. Interest in this specialised subject indeed continues to grow at a rapid rate.

Editor’s Note: This article was originally published in The Afterlife Magazine by The Otherside Press which has since joined the PDN family.

Monday, 28 February 2022

A Brief History of Mediumship Research

Mediumship research began back in the late 1800s. Séances were popular and there were many mediums, both real and fraudulent, cashing in on the public interest. While most of the public believed in the supernatural, many scientists were skeptical and the best of them suspected that fraud was mixed in with some real abilities. This led to the formation of the Society for Psychical Research in 1882. It was intended as a specialized organization dedicated to serious investigation into not just mediumship, but hauntings, poltergeists, telepathy and other paranormal claims.

There were originally many spiritualists on board, in addition to more traditional scientists, which led to a clash of guiding philosophies. The spiritualists felt that the organization should operate from the premise that psychic phenomena were real and that they should be studied more in depth, rather than focusing on proving their existence. They lost out to the more skeptical faction and many of them left the organization.

Early Mediumship Research

The mediumship research was investigative. Researchers would attend séances, control for as much as they could, and observe the mediums in action. There were two types of mediumship: physical and mental. Physical mediumship was far more splashy. Horns sounded, tables rose, knocking was heard, and other phenomena were observed. This was also where the majority of fraud occurred; it’s a problem that still plagues these investigations to this day.

Early Medium’s

Nevertheless, two mediums rose above the rest. Eusapia Palladino and Daniel Dunglas Home. While Palladino would cheat at every opportunity, she would also produce convincing, verifiable phenomena for skeptical researchers when it was clear that cheating wasn’t an option. She was perhaps the most studied medium of her time. And because of her “uncouth” manner and tendency to cheat, she was also very controversial.

Daniel Dunglas Home by contrast, also produced remarkable phenomena, but unlike Palladino, was never caught cheating despite being intensively studied. (There is no first hand account of anyone ever witnessing his attempting to cheat.) There were, of course, allegations of fraud, but they were unsubstantiated.

Harry Houdini: Fraud Buster

mediumship research

Mediums, of course, had their skeptics, the most well known of which was Harry Houdini, the famous magician and escape artist. At first a believer in the afterlife and mediumship in general, he discovered how easy it was to deceive people by posing as a medium himself and employing what was later called the Barnum Effect. (Using generalized information that people take to be specifically about them.)

No one disputes that Houdini uncovered some fraud during his time as a debunker, but there were signs towards the end, in a spectacularly public clash with medium Mina Crandon and the magazine Scientific American, that he had gone off the deep end. He was accused of deliberately attempting to frame Crandon for fraud, argued with everybody and generally made a distasteful nuisance of himself. This is typical of pseudo-skepticism, where a person makes a claim to be an impartial observer and then demonstrates themselves to be so biased against the original claimant that no amount of evidence is convincing to them.

You can generally spot them by their 100% faith in their own opinions, lack of gray areas and absolutely 0% respect for anyone who disagrees with them.

Scientific inquiries into mediumship research in fact, have always been hampered by this type of critic that imagines flaws and/or fraud in everything they see. More on this later.

The Difficulty of Testing Mediums

Mediumship research, even within parapsychology, has received little attention over the past decades and only recently has interest begun to increase as a result of relatively recent research. One of the problems with mediumship studies is that there are possibilities for biases all over the place. Sitters, who are the judges of their own readings, (because only they possess all the necessary facts about themselves) can be biased either for or against mediumship and they can be vulnerable to Barnum statements. Mediums can take cues from body language and unconscious signaling or even from the sound of someone’s voice. You can also ruin experiments with faulty scoring.

The sitters need to be properly pre-screened and the mediums need to be capable of doing what they claim they can do. It does no one any good to test using unreliable sitters and incompetent mediums.

But you also need to present the medium with a comfortable and natural atmosphere to do their work and avoid over-designing controls into the process, such as having the sitters all be roughly the same age, from the same area and a similar socioeconomic background. (This adds an unnecessary level of complexity to the reading. Information about age, locations and backgrounds will be harder to distinguish from other sitters.) Other problems include overworking or rushing the medium on any given day.

There is so much that can go wrong.

The First Modern Effort For Mediumship Research

Accounting for all of this can be daunting and requires great attention to detail and a solid experimental design. In 1999, Professor Gary Schwartz of the University of Arizona, conducted the first modern mediumship research experiments, and had partial success(You can read a somewhat critical, but fair peer review of his work here.)

There was a back and forth of criticism and rebuttal with Professor Emeritus Ray Hyman of the University of Oregon, but because of further research and improvements in study design, it’s completely irrelevant at this point. I’ll refer to the Wikipedia stub article, which has the necessary links.

His somewhat flawed mediumship research led to various studies in the early 2000’s, many of which were criticized for the reasons stated above. A skeptic’s study by psychologist Ciaran O’Keeffe and Professor Richard Wiseman for example, put mediums alone in a room for over five hours giving multiple readings, chose sitters that were far too similar in age and background and failed to do trial runs. (Unsurprisingly, they failed.)

Mediumship Experimentation Lessons

Side note: having failed to learn anything from his previous mediumship experiment, and not taking any cues from much better research that had already been published, Professor Richard Wiseman, along with Professor Chris French, together managed to create the most gawd awful mediumship test imaginable. It is better described as a skeptic publicity stunt and is not part of the scientific literature.

The medium had to WRITE ten readings over the course of an eight hour day for a collection of students who were all roughly the same age from the same school. As if that wasn’t bad enough, they blacked out sections of the readings and then handed them over to the students to see if they could pick out whose was whose. The medium, Patricia Putt, who had never claimed to be able to write out readings, unsurprisingly did not get a single match.

A Difficult Learning Period

Other mediumship research studies were criticized for insufficient blinding, pre-screening problems and sensory leakage. The result of all of these false starts was an improvement in the design of mediumship testing. The researchers worked out how to remove the flaws and still provide the mediums with a natural flow. The pre-screening of sitters got better and the researchers learned what sort of blinded testing mediums were capable of.

The Triple Blinded Experiment

By 2006 most of these issues had been solved. Gary Schwartz teamed up with researcher Julie Beischel to create a triple blinded research study. The study shows just how difficult it is to navigate all the different problems associated with testing mediums.

The sitters were pre-screened to ensure that they had actually lost someone they wanted to communicate with and so that they could be trusted to competently complete the trial they were in. They were given both dummy readings and the real ones and asked to rate them. The dummy readings gave the researchers insight into how the person did their scoring so that their responses could be weighted according to the biases they demonstrated, either for or against mediumship and it gave a baseline for chance results.

The mediums were properly screened as well so that the researchers could be sure they were dealing with a competent person. During the test, the medium only dealt with a proxy sitter who was blinded to the actual sitter. When the sitter got their reading results, they were blinded to which one was actually the correct one. The experimenters were blinded to both the medium and the sitter. So the medium, the sitter and the experimenter were all blinded by protocol. Even with all these controls, the mediums still outperformed chance results.

Now that there was finally a proper experiment for others to replicate, various research groups took up the challenge and in 2020 a meta analysis of 14 different studies for a total of 18 different experiments showed that mediums could indeed pass a sufficiently controlled test of their abilities.

The Advancement of Mediumship Research

There was soon a list of certified research mediums to draw upon, which in turn led to other research. Having a group of people in which their psychic ability was confirmed meant that they could be studied for similarities in their physiology, psychology and what mental state they were in while they were giving readings.

What they discovered was that mediums in general experienced good mental health overall, but did worse than average when under emotional distress. This is consistent with highly sensitive people in general. In addition, they definitely entered a different physiological state when they were giving readings. Afterwards they experienced relaxation, clarity and happiness.

Critics

There are several things to be learned from this. Criticisms of the initial study designs came from within the parapsychological community, not outside skeptics. Parapsychologists as a group were perfectly capable of seeing the initial flaws in the research and correcting them, just like in any other scientific field. Critics like Ray Hyman were ultimately just noise in the system.

When a couple of skeptics did conduct a study, (Wiseman and O’Keeffe, 2004) their unique experiment was crude and poorly designed and they failed to achieve significant results. They seemed to not have much of a feel for the research and their suggestions for further research were either obvious or unneeded. The progress of mediumship research seems to have not needed their efforts. Wiseman, as far as I’ve been able to discern, has never done a successful psi study of any kind.

One thing I find interesting here is that this relatively small part of parapsychology has flown under the radar, overshadowed by psychologist Dr Daryl Bem’s precognition research. Without the publicity, it hasn’t attracted as much skeptical wrath. It’s a pattern I’ve seen over the years. Skeptics tend to focus the most attention on subjects that reach a wider audience and tend to ignore those that don’t. I will let the reader reach their own conclusions about why that is.

The mediumship studies make an excellent case study for how science works. You try, you fail, you learn, you try again. Once you get it right, it’s time for replications. It’s an evolution of experimental design. And a good study can yield information that informs still more studies, continuing the process of learning through science.